February 12, 2012

1965- Supremes sessions 1

.....At Motown, The Supremes were sort of the queens of covers. In the assembly line business model of the label's early days there were people whose specialty was songwriting, others who produced, others who performed, etc., and so every artist at some time drew on material written by someone else, even when the result would be considered an entirely in-house product to the audience. The difference with The Supremes is that they released not only a record number of themed albums, but what must have been a record number of themes: Broadway, country, The Beatles, Sam Cooke, more Broadway and also continuously recording Holland-Dozier-Holland originals. Don Waller's "The Motown Story" (Scribner's, 1985) lists six albums in 1965 alone. The last one was for Christmas.

.....Unlike many Motown recordings, the instrumentals were recorded in L. A., rather than in the basement in Detroit. According to the liner notes for the remastered edition (1999) of LP MERRY CHRISTMAS, "Band tracks recorded in Los Angeles, CA, August, 1965. Vocals recorded in Detroit, MI, September, 1965." On the original jackets (located last year on Discogs), the mono edition credited Harvey Fuqua alone as the producer. The stereo edition credited Harvey Fuqua and Davis & Gordon. That would be Hal Davis and Marc Gordon, their full names given in arrangement credits and elsewhere. The dates of completion (presumably the final vocal takes or any last minute overdubbed instrumental work) were found on the excellent Don't Forget The Motor City website and are the ones I used as the basis for the following chronology of the sessions.

.....There is one song for which I have not been able to find a producer's credit for the original source tapes nor a date for the vocal take. It was first released on CD MERRY CHRISTMAS Motown/Universal 012 153 355-2 (US) 10/12/99, the remaster of the 1965 album. All songs in this post can be found on it, unless otherwise noted.
  • 01:59 "NÖEL" (Traditional) This song was previously recorded and released by The Miracles, as were most of the first few Christmas songs The Supremes attempted. Their version used only the first of nine verses plus the chorus. The Supremes add the second verse.
.....From CD THE NEVER-BEFORE-RELEASED MASTERS Motown/MCA MCD09075MD (Japan/US) 07/87
  • 02:11 "THE CHRISTMAS SONG" (Mel Tormé, Robert Wells) This song was also on the 1963 Miracles album. Recorded 08/26/65.
.....From CD A MOTOWN CHRISTMAS VOLUME 2 Motown/Universal 440 016 364-2 (US) 11/06/01
  • 02:55 "OH HOLY NIGHT" (Adolphe C. Adam) Florence Ballard sings lead here, one of four songs recorded 09/09/65. Again, this song was previously recorded by the Miracles, but it was the last of those to be shelved. Three others made it onto the Supremes' album.
.....From LP MERRY CHRISTMAS Motown MT(mono) or MS(stereo) 638 (US) 11/01/65
  • 02:40 "RUDOLPH THE RED-NOSED REINDEER" (Johnny Marks) Recorded 09/09/65, the most famous version must be the Gene Autry single. Although this is the first version released by a Motown act, it would be eclipsed by the single from The Temptations a few years later. The Supremes' version rarely shows up on Motown compilations, appearing once on a UK-only LP in 1973 and again on a Flintstones tie-in in 1996.
  • 02:40 "SANTA CLAUS IS COMING TO TOWN" (Haven Gillespie, J. Fred Coots) Recorded 09/09/65 and previously recorded by The Miracles. After this version was included on the 1968 label compilation it became overshadowed in 1970 when it was covered again as a Jackson 5 A-side. It didn't return to domestic compilations until the Flintstones tie-in mentioned above.
  • 02:50 "MY FAVORITE THINGS" (Richard Rogers, Oscar Hammerstein II) Recorded 09/09/65. Aside from a line about "silver white winters" and another about "packages tied up with strings" there's really nothing in this song to suggest Christmas, but the tenuous connections to the season must have been justification enough to include it. It originates in the stage musical "The Sound Of Music" which had been adapted into a movie released in the spring of 1965. The stage play was wildly successful but the movie would become a commercial juggernaut, breaking box office records and yielding a soundtrack album that became the best selling album of the 1960's, dwarfing even the Beatles. However, once The Supremes placed this song in a Christmas context, the MOR world followed suit. Barbara Streisand included it on her LP A CHRISTMAS ALBUM Columbia CS9557 (US) 10/67 and it was soon accepted as a holiday standard.
  • 03:52 "WHITE CHRISTMAS" (Irving Berlin) Recorded 09/14/65 and the second selection also covered by The Miracles to make the cut. This was the lead track, in fact. It is a paradox of Christmas music that the most ubiquitous songs are the most rerecorded. The whole point of recording a song is so that you don't have to perform it repeatedly; you can simply play back the recording. Of all the songs on LP MERRY CHRISTMAS, this and "SILVER BELLS" resurface on the most compilations.
  • 02:09 "JOY TO THE WORLD" (Traditional, arranged and adapted by Hal Davis, Marc Gordon and Harvey Fuqua) Recorded 09/14/65 and along with "MY FAVORITE THINGS" it ranks closely after "WHITE CHRISTMAS" and "SILVER BELLS" as the most frequently reissued tracks Motown's Christmas collections. The song itself has had a convoluted history, briefly summarized by Ian Bradley in "The Penguin Book of Carols" (Penguin 1999). From its origins as an interpretation of Psalm 98 by Isaac Watts in 1719 it underwent nearly continuous revision, lyrical and musical, until as late as 1955. The music most likely began as a tune called "COMFORT" arranged or possibly composed in 1833 by Thomas Hawkes, who intended it to be the musical accompaniment for the poems/prayers of Charles Wesley. Later publishers attributed the music to the then dead (and not collecting royalties) Handel, incorporating bits from Handel's "Messiah" oratario to make the claim convincing. One such publisher was Lowell Mason, who renamed the song "ANTIOCH" in 1836. Like most performers, The Supremes sing only the first, second and fourth verses, skipping the darker third verse about "sin's curse".
  • 02:25 "LITTLE BRIGHT STAR" (Allan Capps, Mary Dean) Recorded 09/14/65. This was the same songwriting team responsible for the hit Cher song "HALF BREED" in the early 1970's. At about this time producers Davis & Gordon also worked on the Chris Clark recording of the Capps/Dean song "SOFT TOUCH". Clark was briefly on Motown's V.I.P. label, then Motown, then Weed, none of which released the song. I tried finding an earlier recording, or even a date for filing the song, but I couldn't find much about either writer prior to this except that Capps had also worked for Hanna-Barbera in 1965. Unless someone can leave a comment with evidence to the contrary, I'm going to assume this is the first appearance of an original Christmas song.
.....That's as good a place as any to wrap up this post. The second half of the sessions will be covered tomorrow.

February 11, 2012

1965- "New Year's" (spoken)

.....While most people are aware that Motown artists in the 1960's not only played individual headlining shows but travelled as a collective identity as the Motor Town Revue, many are not aware that later incarnations of that revue were MC'ed by Willie Tyler, best known for his ventriloquist act Willie Tyler and Lester. Tyler has had a varied carrier (with and without Lester) acting in movies and television and also writing and singing original songs. On his website is an audio clip for "CHRISTMAS RAP" and a video clip for "DECEMBER AGAIN". If I can confirm that they were recorded before 2000 I may post on them in the future. This post is about a routine from one of his comedy albums. Bits from the album have turned up on Youtube but I have yet to hear this. I'm mentioning it here on faith that it's relevant to the season but can't really review it without hearing it.
  • 00:00 "NEW YEAR'S" (Willie Tyler) (spoken word)
  • performed by Willie Tyler and Lester
  • original source: LP HELLO DUMMY! Tamla T265 (US) 11/65
  • and my source: (still waiting)

February 10, 2012

1964- "Purple Snowflakes" (addenda)

.....The second known Christmas recording by Marvin Gaye also remained unreleased until the 1990's, but is of greater interest (to me, anyway) because it was an original composition. There are two mixes that I know of, one mono and one stereo, and I made note of them in last year's post. The link to that post would be here:


.....What I can add here are the redundant appearances, of which there are a few. I've listed below everything I've been able to find.
  • VACD CHRISTMAS IN THE CITY Motown Master Series 37463-6326-2 (Germany) 10/19/93
  • VACD A CHRISTMAS PRESENT FROM MOTOWN- VOLUME ONE Spectrum 544 672-2 (UK) 10/05/01
  • VACD A MOTOWN CHRISTMAS VOLUME TWO Motown/Universal 440 016 364-2 (US) 11/06/01
  • VACD 20TH CENTURY MASTERS- THE CHRISTMAS COLLECTION: THE BEST OF MOTOWN CHRISTMAS VOLUME TWO Motown/Universal 602498-83491-6 (US) 09/13/05
  • VA2CD THE ULTIMATE MOTOWN CHRISTMAS COLLECTION Motown/Universal B0013383-02 (US) 10/13/09
.....One quick note: the Funk Brothers' recording of "WINTER WONDERLAND" which was chronologically placed after "PURPLE SNOWFLAKES" last year has been relocated from 1965 to 1968 owing to the number of other mistakes in the liner notes to CHRISTMAS IN THE CITY, where the 1965 date originated. But it should be pointed out that from its first appearance its availability has been almost identical to the list above with the only difference being that it is found on Volume One of the 20th Century Master compilation, not Volume Two. Being secular seasonal songs rather than strictly Christmas songs and both having debuted on the same disc decades after their recording they may be thought of as somehow kindred, or they may be an indication of whether the intended effect of a compilation is meant to be weighted for variety (with as many different artists as possible) or weighted for familiarity (using the three act with the largest Christmas catalogues: The Temptations, The Miracles and The Supremes).

February 9, 2012

The Miracles on compilations

.....As the first full Christmas album from the Motown group of labels, the 1963 LP CHRISTMAS WITH THE MIRACLES should have had the most opportunities to be represented on seasonal compilations. However, as the earlier posts this month attest, all other recordings made prior to its release either remained out of print or unheard entirely until 1990. Thus, there were no compilations until 1968, at which point two other original albums were out (from The Supremes and Stevie Wonder). The first compilation had a modicum of new material but otherwise drew from the three earlier albums. The only track from that first Miracles album used was the only original song, "CHRISTMAS EVERYDAY". In fact, although the album was routinely in print and the Miracles were a staple of the company's occasional Christmas compilations it would be over thirty years before any other song from the album appeared on a company compilation. Songs were usually drawn from the new 1968 material or their second Christmas album, out in 1970. The albums which carried "CHRISTMAS EVERYDAY" during that time were:
  • VALP MERRY CHRISTMAS FROM MOTOWN Motown MS681 (US) 12/06/68
  • VALP CHRISTMAS GIFT WRAP Motown MS713 (US) 10/70 (same as 1968)
  • VALP IT'S CHRISTMAS IN MOTOWN Music For Pleasure SPR90010 (UK) c.1973
  • VALP WE WISH YOU A MERRY CHRISTMAS Natural Resources NR4011 (US) 10/78
  • VACD MERRY CHRISTMAS FROM MOTOWN MCA Special Products 737463850025 (US) 11/24/93 (This is not the same as the 1968/1970 album, no matter what the Barnes & Noble website tells you. It just has the same title.) This was reissued in 1996 with a different catalog number.
.....Over the next two decades each of the songs from the 1963 album appears on at least one compilation, with the possible exception of "SILVER BELLS", which is always presented by other performers. The largest sampling is found on CD OUR VERY BEST CHRISTMAS Uptown/Universal 153 356 2 (US) 10/12/99, which draws six songs from the first album and nine from the second, plus a new song from the 1968 compilation. Anyone interested in getting the traditional covers would be best served by getting the entire album; anyone looking only for the one original song would be better off getting it on any of a number of compilations that would also have otherwise scarce songs, such as the double disc VA2CD THE ULTIMATE MOTOWN CHRISTMAS COLLECTION Motown/Universal B0013383-02 (US) 10/13/09.

February 8, 2012

1963- Miracles' album sessions 2

.....I still haven't found specific dates for Pete Moore's military service. Hopefully more details about his life may surface this spring when the Miracles are belatedly inducted into the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame. (Bizarrely, Smokey Robinson was inducted in 1987, 25 years ago, with no mention of the Miracles being nominated.) If and when that happens I'll leave a comment to the effect here and with the 1962 post (February 4th, 2012) specifying which dates Moore was available.

.....Finishing the album long before its seasonal release, Ron White produced two sessions. The first was on July 17th, 1963:
  • 01:55 "SANTA CLAUS IS COMING TO TOWN" (Haven Gillespie. J. Fred Coots)
  • 01:42 "LET IT SNOW, LET IT SNOW, LET IT SNOW" (Jules Styne, Sammy Cahn)
.....and the second session was August 8th, 1963:
  • 02:20 "WINTER WONDERLAND" (Felix Bernard, Dick Smith)
  • 03:05 "WHITE CHRISTMAS" (Irving Berlin)
  • 02:03 "SILVER BELLS" (Jay Livingston, Ray Evans)
.....There was a later unrelated session produced by Brian Holland and Lamont Dozier on August 23rd in which the Miracles recorded the non-seasonal specific "DANCIN' HOLIDAY" (Marc Jean). That song appeared on the album DOIN' MICKEY'S MONKEY just two weeks after the Christmas album. Speaking of which, the first Motown Christmas album greeted the world as LP CHRISTMAS WITH THE MIRACLES Tamla TM236 (US) 10/29/63. For more detailed explanations of the covers of traditional songs, see last year's posts at:




.....The following post will list compilations that draw from the album.

February 7, 2012

1963- "Everyday's A Holiday"

.....Before reading this post about a Tri-Phi Records release, I'd recommend first reading the February 2, 2012 post about Wreg Tracey because it briefly explains the label's connection to Motown.


.....I haven't been able to find any biographical information about the Ervin Sisters. When Gwen Gordy's three labels were absorbed in the Motown group, the Ervin Sisters didn't survive as an act, but I haven't found if they joined any of the vocal groups around at the time. These are the only two releases credited to them.
  • -N/A- "CHANGING BABY" (The Ervin Sisters)
  • -N/A- b/w "PLEASE DO IT RIGHT" (The Ervin Sisters)
  • original source: 7" Tri-Phi Records TP1014 (US) 07/14/62
.....and the object of today's post:
  • 02:38 "EVERYDAY'S A HOLIDAY" (Thomas Kemp, Robert White)
  • -N/A- b/w "WHY I LOVE HIM" (Betty Ervin, Phyllis Ervin, Harvey Fuqua)
  • original source: 7" Tri-Phi Records TP1022 (US) 01/63 or 03/63
.....If, as was common in this period, all four tracks were recorded at the same session, then this should precede the Kim Weston entry. All I have is a vague release date. I would be more concerned about placement except that there is some question as to whether this would be considered seasonal let alone a Christmas song. Many accepted Christmas songs don't mention the holiday or even anything related to it, so this choice is definitely subjective. Judge for yourself, if this Youtube link is still working:



February 6, 2012

1962- "The Christmas Song" (Marvin Gaye)

.....This was a live recording from the Apollo Theater, New York, NY on December 16, 1962. Obviously that would be too late to release for that year's holiday sales, but neither the Miracles' sessions in August or the Kim Weston song recorded in October led to any releases that year either, so I'm not certain if there were clear plans for this recording when it was captured. Because of conflicting liner notes from different sources the post that I put together last year was confused and probably confusing. What is certain is that the song was originally recorded by Nat 'King' Cole and written by Mel Tormé and Robert Wells. As a cover it should not be given any priority on this blog but I'm including it as a part of Motown's history with Christmas music as a whole. As for the conflicting liner notes, I should just list all the sources I've been able to find.

.....First, the original appearance in 4CD THE MARVIN GAYE COLLECTION Motown MOTD4-6311 (US) 09/19/90
  • Live from the Apollo 1963, previously unreleased
  • Mixed from the original masters by Roger Nichols
  • Producer: William Stevenson; Compilation Producer: George Soloman
  • Mastered by John Matousek at Soundworks West, Los Angeles, CA
.....That first appearance lists the running time at 2:22, but other appearances range from 2:35 to 2:38. It first appeared in an all-Christmas context in VACD CHRISTMAS IN THE CITY Motown Master Series 37463-6326-2 (Germany) 10/19/93
  • Produced by Smokey Robinson
  • First issued on the album THE MARVIN GAYE COLLECTION Motown 6311, 09/19/90
  • Recorded live at the Apollo Theater, 1963
  • Compilation produced by Cary E. Mansfield
  • Digitally remastered by Bill Inglot and Dan Hersch at Digiprep, Los Angeles, CA
.....I don't own a copy of VACD A CHRISTMAS PRESENT FROM MOTOWN VOLUME 2 Spectrum 544 684-2 (UK) 10/05/01, although I've learned that both this CD and Volume 1 (released simultaneously) contain 18 tracks. While Spectrum is generally a budget label dealing in repackagings of licensed recordings, that seems to be more generous than you'd find on a loss-leader. They could have song-writing and even producing credits but it's unlikely that there would be revealing or elaborate liner notes and certainly not investigations into the recording's history. Leave a comment if you've found otherwise.

.....The next appearance changes the recording dates, but doesn't name a producer. At this point there's one vote for Mickey, one for Smokey, one absentee and this makes one abstention. From VACD A MOTOWN CHRISTMAS VOLUME 2 Motown/Universal 440 016 364-2 (US) 11/06/01 :
  • Recorded on stage at the Apollo Theater, New York, NY, probably December 16, 1962
  • First issued with a different mix on the box set THE MARVIN GAYE COLLECTION Motown 6311, Sept 1990
  • Compilation produced by Harry Weinger
  • Digitally remastered from original sources by Kevin Reeves at Universal Mastering Studios-East
  • Mixed by Kevin Reeves
.....The difference between the 1993 mix and the 2001 mix is mostly that the crowd noises at the beginning are more distinct. Actually in both mixes Gaye's voice comes through remarkably clearly for a decades old live recording. It sounds as though he's accompanied by piano and flute and the subtleties of the fluttering of the flute are easier to hear in the 2001 mix. I'd considered the possibility that the song had been recorded twice but the instrumental arrangements and Gaye's address to the crowd are identical. I'm convinced that they're the same recording, and more importantly so is Keith Hughes. Hughes has had access to Motown's paperwork during the course of doing research for the liner notes of some of Motown's higher end boxed sets and has compiled the website Don't Forget The Motor City. The entry there for this song notes that the appearance on the 1990 box is in stereo but the 1993 and 2001 mixes are in mono. It also places the date at December 31 (?), 1962 and confirms that William Stevenson produced it. Stevenson also produced the live album LP RECORDED LIVE: MARVIN GAYE ON STAGE Tamla TM242 (US) 09/09/63, recorded August 4th. The New Year's Eve date is the same one given for tracks from the various artists' album LP MOTORTOWN REVUE VOL. 1 RECORDED LIVE! AT THE APOLLO Motown M609 (US) 04/23/63. That album includes other Marvin Gaye songs, but they were all produced by Berry Gordy. After the live Gaye album (recorded at Graystone Ballroom in August 1963) there was another live Motortown Revue album recorded November 17, 1963 and produced by Mickey Stevenson but it was recorded at the Fox Theater, Detroit. If anyone has inside information that can get the date, location and producer to line up, please leave the information and your source in the comments below. Thanks.

February 5, 2012

1962- Wish You A Merry Christmas (stereo)

.....I posted about Kim Weston's "WISH YOU A MERRY CHRISTMAS" last year, but neglected to mention that an alternate mix exists and that many compilations containing the song don't distinguish between the two. First, you may want to read the original post:


.....The different versions are the original monaural version discussed in that post, which appears on:
  • VACD CHRISTMAS IN THE CITY Motown Master Series 37463-6326-2 (Germany) 10/19/93
  • VACD A CHRISTMAS PRESENT FROM MOTOWN VOLUME 2 Spectrum 544 684-2 (UK) 10/05/01
.....At about the same time that Spectrum/Universal licensed the earlier version for Europe, a previously unreleased stereo mix was released in the United States. At 2:47 it was twelve seconds longer and had a noticeably better dynamic range; the difference between the softest and loudest parts was more pronounced whereas the monaural version seems to spend too much time "in the red". Without so much distortion listeners get more of an indication of the headliner she would be in just a few years. The new mix is credited to Kevin Reeves, who also handled new mixes of "X-MAS TWIST" and two Marvin Gaye songs. The liner notes give a more specific recording date, October 31, 1962. There's also a change in the song-writing credit: it adds Kim Weston's name to William 'Mickey' Stevenson's. While the monaural version continued to show up on European compilations (especially those that licensed tracks from sources besides Universal) the stereo version appeared in the U.S. three times in one decade:
  • VACD A MOTOWN CHRISTMAS VOLUME 2 Motown/Universal 440 016 364-2 (US) 11/06/01
  • VACD 20TH CENTURY MASTERS: THE CHRISTMAS COLLECTION-- THE BEST OF MOTOWN CHRISTMAS [VOLUME 1] Motown/Universal 602498-60566-0 (US) 09/23/03
  • VA2CD THE ULTIMATE MOTOWN CHRISTMAS COLLECTION Motown/Universal B0013383-02 (US) 10/13/09
.....From repeated listenings I'm certain that both mixes use the same take as a source. Both start abruptly, although the stereo sounds as though it starts a half-second later. The greater difference is at the end. While the monaural mix fades out, the stereo has a longer edit and an entire additional line, "Oh, I've got to be with you..." before fading out.

February 4, 2012

1962- Miracles' album sessions 1

.....In August 1962 the Miracles began recording Christmas songs. These songs eventually became half of their first Christmas album the following year, but I don't know if the intention was to record a few secular holiday tunes and a few religious carols and pick through them for a likely single, or if it was always the intention to produce an entire album.

.....The first three tracks were finished August 21, 1962. They were:
  • 2:39 "THE CHRISTMAS SONG" (Mel Tormé, Robert Wells), produced by William 'Mickey' Stevenson.
  • 2:11 "O HOLY NIGHT" (Adolphe C. Adam), produced by Ron White and Smokey Robinson.
  • 2:29 "CHRISTMAS EVERYDAY" (William 'Smokey' Robinson), produced by Smokey Robinson.
.....After the album was released in late October 1963 a promotional single circulated coupling the original song "CHRISTMAS EVERYDAY" with the cover "THE CHRISTMAS SONG" as 7" Tamla EX-009 (US) 11/63.

.....Another session was held on August 23, 1962:
  • 2:30 "NÖEL" (Traditional), produced by Smokey Robinson.
.....And at least one more on August 29, 1962:
  • 2:27 "I'LL BE HOME FOR CHRISTMAS" (lyrics: Kim Gannon, music: Walter Kent, for legal purposes Buck Ram), produced by Ron White.
.....If that last songwriting credit seems a little cryptic, my apologies, but I've already provided capsule backgrounds to these songs with a track-by-track look at the album last year in the three posts linked below:




.....I'll place the remainder of the sessions chronologically.

February 3, 2012

1961- "X-Mas Twist" (two edits)

.....This song was mentioned last year, but I have found two different edits and mixes since that post was written. I've just reread the original post and while most of the text could be rewritten many of the basic facts remain the same. I should start by giving the details of the original releases:
  • -N/A- "WHITE HOUSE TWIST" (Brian Holland, Berry Gordy, Barney Ales)
  • 02:44 b/w "X-MAS TWIST" (Berry Gordy, Barney Ales)
  • performed by The Twistin' Kings [aka Funk Brothers]
  • original source: 7" Motown M1022 (US) 11/27/61
  • and my source: VA2CD THE ULTIMATE MOTOWN CHRISTMAS COLLECTION Motown/Universal B0013383-02 (US) 2009
.....That was followed by the full album LP TWISTIN' THE WORLD AROUND Motown MLP 601[mono] (US) 11/29/61 and later Motown MT-601 (US) [stereo]:
  • [A1] OLD FOLKS TWIST
  • [A2] WHITE HOUSE TWIST
  • [A3] TWISTIN' THE WORLD AROUND
  • [A4] TWIST A LA B.G.
  • [A5] FLYING CIRCLE TWIST
  • [B1] MEXICAN TWIST
  • [B2] CONGO TWIST PART 1
  • [B3] CONGO TWIST PART 2
  • [B4] CHRISTMAS TWIST [same as X-MAS TWIST]
  • [B5] TWISTING ALES STYLE
.....There was a second, non-Christmas single:
  • -N/A- "CONGO TWIST PART 1" (Berry Gordy, Barney Ales, Loucye Gordy Wakefield)
  • -N/A- b/w "CONGO TWIST PART 2" (Berry Gordy, Barney Ales, Loucye Gordy Wakefield)
  • performed by The Twistin' Kings [aka Funk Brothers]
  • original source: 7" Motown M1023 (US) 12/18/61
.....All of the album tracks were recorded from November 18th to 22nd and produced by Berry Gordy except for the "CONGO TWIST", which was produced by Gordy and Barney Ales. The six songs not appearing on singles were written by Gordy and Ales.
.....The next two paragraphs are reworked slightly from last year's post...

.....Compared to much of the rest of the label's Christmas material, it was a bit of a throwback. It more closely resembled the jazz and swing singles and 78's of the 1930's and early 1950's than the Miracles or the Supremes. If it seems odd that the Funk Brothers here don't quite sound like most Motown singles, bear in mind that this was a rush job ordered by label owner Berry Gordy to cash in on a dance craze. If there are any Motown fans out there who don't recognize the name Barney Ales, it's because he was the VP of Sales. The fact that he's got a writing credit on every song gives you some indication that the objectives here were not to create a lasting product. Oh, and one of the songs on the album is actually called "Twisting Ales Style", as though the audience would know what that meant.

.....For more (and more authoritative) information on the Funk Brothers, I would recommend the book (and subsequent documentary film) "Standing In The Shadows of Motown". Relevant to this song, I can only say that the line-ups for most Motown recordings of this period are almost never 100% confirmable. The Funk Brothers weren't exactly a band, per se, but a pool of musicians. At any given time during Motown's residency in Detroit (roughly until 1972 when most operations moved to California, creating 'Mo-west') there were 8-12 musicians in the pool. Producers would form ad hoc groups by selecting 3-6 of them, sometimes recording several vocalists over the same Funk Brothers instrumental track and letting Gordy pick his favorite to be released as an A-side. Sometimes the other vocal takes would later be used as B-sides or album tracks. The only personnel for this song that I could confirm (courtesy of Discogs) would be:
  • Vocals (and possibly saxophone) by Thomas "Beans" Bowles
  • Piano by Joe Hunter
  • Saxophone by Ron Wakefield
.....but there are probably others. For more details I'll refer you to the excellent blog Motown Junkies,
which specializes in the label's singles. The following link:.....

http://motownjunkies.wordpress.com/2010/04/23/138/

.....should lead you to the page for "X-MAS TWIST", at the bottom of which you'll find a link to the page for the A-side. Enjoy.

.....What I couldn't discuss last year was the much longer unedited version which I found in a cache of Christmas music I came across in storage this past fall. I found it on VACD A MOTOWN CHRISTMAS VOLUME 2 Motown/Universal 440 016 364-2 (US) 11/06/01. The back of the jewel case simply refers to it as the "complete version". The liner notes describe it as the "previously unreleased unedited stereo version" and note that it was edited and in mono when it appeared on the 1961 album. Unedited, it runs 7:12 and opens with a solo organ (a single finger, it sounds like) playing a few lifeless bars from the chorus of "JINGLE BELLS". It then launches directly into the original number, which is the point at which the edited single begins. The stereo mix has a slightly cleaner sound than I've noticed on other sources, but knowing that it was recorded and released in roughly a week by veteran session men I would expect that it was created in low-fidelity live-in-the-studio circumstances and that the source tapes don't leave much room for improvement. Once it runs the length of the single it continues vamping for four and a half minutes. There's an organ solo and a guitar solo but no new verses.

.....The one CD source I was aware of last year was VA6CD THE COMPLETE MOTOWN SINGLES VOLUME 1: 1959-1961 Hip-O-Select B0003631-02 (US) Jan/2005, which I still do not own. It contains the single edit.

.....The second version I could find is also the single edit (2:44), found on VA2CD THE ULTIMATE MOTOWN CHRISTMAS COLLECTION Motown/Universal B0013383-02 (US) 2009. It has no liner notes to speak of other than perfunctory songwriting and producer credits. The sound is only slightly harsher than the stereo version but since the stereo version is almost three times longer with no additional verses, I would have to say that the single edit may be more practical when planning a compilation.